Comic Book Men poster
★ 7.7
Comic Book Men poster

Overall Rating

★ 7.7
S5 E6
#1
★ 8.3

Stan Saves!

Stan Lee drops by the Stash and helps the guys with a customer experiencing a comics crisis. A customer buys a classic issue of Fantastic Four.

S5 E10
#2
★ 8.0

Tell 'Em, Jim Lee!

Artist Jim Lee shares tales from the world of comics on the podcast; a comic book brings wedding bells to the Stash.

S5 E1
#3
★ 7.9

Wookiee Fever

Peter Mayhew (best known for playing "Chewbacca" in Star Wars) judges a Wookiee contest at the Stash.

S5 E8
#4
★ 7.8

Royal Romita

Legendary comics artist John Romita Jr. draws an original piece for the Stash. Bryan’s interest is piqued by an Evel Knievel toy from his childhood.

S5 E2
#5
★ 7.6

Holy Zap Copter!

Mike flies in the original '66 Batcopter to celebrate 15 years working at the Secret Stash. Also, one of the hottest comic books of the '90s enters the Stash.

S5 E3
#6
★ 7.6

Captain and the Clerk

Kevin talks comics with actor William Shatner and Walt covets a Mego doll that has unique packaging.

S5 E4
#7
★ 7.4

Bryan Gets Bit

The guys and Bryan visit a "Jaws" museum; super-powered toilet paper comes through.

S5 E5
#8
★ 7.4

Stash-pocalypse

A hot zombie comic prompts the guys to reconsider their apocalyptic preparations. An eccentric collector comes seeking Walt's help.

S5 E9
#9
★ 7.0

Suburban Cowboys

An old pal inspires the gang to don their cowboy hats and journey back to the old Wild West. A customer comes in seeking an iconic ’80s comic.

S5 E7
#10
★ 6.6

Making Clay

Walt and Bryan audition the Secret Stash employees for a role in their new claymation film with friend and fellow podcaster Brian Quinn.

S5 E7
#1
★ 6.6

Making Clay

Walt and Bryan audition the Secret Stash employees for a role in their new claymation film with friend and fellow podcaster Brian Quinn.

S5 E9
#2
★ 7.0

Suburban Cowboys

An old pal inspires the gang to don their cowboy hats and journey back to the old Wild West. A customer comes in seeking an iconic ’80s comic.

S5 E4
#3
★ 7.4

Bryan Gets Bit

The guys and Bryan visit a "Jaws" museum; super-powered toilet paper comes through.

S5 E5
#4
★ 7.4

Stash-pocalypse

A hot zombie comic prompts the guys to reconsider their apocalyptic preparations. An eccentric collector comes seeking Walt's help.

S5 E2
#5
★ 7.6

Holy Zap Copter!

Mike flies in the original '66 Batcopter to celebrate 15 years working at the Secret Stash. Also, one of the hottest comic books of the '90s enters the Stash.

S5 E3
#6
★ 7.6

Captain and the Clerk

Kevin talks comics with actor William Shatner and Walt covets a Mego doll that has unique packaging.

S5 E8
#7
★ 7.8

Royal Romita

Legendary comics artist John Romita Jr. draws an original piece for the Stash. Bryan’s interest is piqued by an Evel Knievel toy from his childhood.

S5 E1
#8
★ 7.9

Wookiee Fever

Peter Mayhew (best known for playing "Chewbacca" in Star Wars) judges a Wookiee contest at the Stash.

S5 E10
#9
★ 8.0

Tell 'Em, Jim Lee!

Artist Jim Lee shares tales from the world of comics on the podcast; a comic book brings wedding bells to the Stash.

S5 E6
#10
★ 8.3

Stan Saves!

Stan Lee drops by the Stash and helps the guys with a customer experiencing a comics crisis. A customer buys a classic issue of Fantastic Four.

S5 E1
★ 7.9

Wookiee Fever

Peter Mayhew (best known for playing "Chewbacca" in Star Wars) judges a Wookiee contest at the Stash.

S5 E2
★ 7.6

Holy Zap Copter!

Mike flies in the original '66 Batcopter to celebrate 15 years working at the Secret Stash. Also, one of the hottest comic books of the '90s enters the Stash.

S5 E3
★ 7.6

Captain and the Clerk

Kevin talks comics with actor William Shatner and Walt covets a Mego doll that has unique packaging.

S5 E4
★ 7.4

Bryan Gets Bit

The guys and Bryan visit a "Jaws" museum; super-powered toilet paper comes through.

S5 E5
★ 7.4

Stash-pocalypse

A hot zombie comic prompts the guys to reconsider their apocalyptic preparations. An eccentric collector comes seeking Walt's help.

S5 E6
★ 8.3

Stan Saves!

Stan Lee drops by the Stash and helps the guys with a customer experiencing a comics crisis. A customer buys a classic issue of Fantastic Four.

S5 E7
★ 6.6

Making Clay

Walt and Bryan audition the Secret Stash employees for a role in their new claymation film with friend and fellow podcaster Brian Quinn.

S5 E8
★ 7.8

Royal Romita

Legendary comics artist John Romita Jr. draws an original piece for the Stash. Bryan’s interest is piqued by an Evel Knievel toy from his childhood.

S5 E9
★ 7.0

Suburban Cowboys

An old pal inspires the gang to don their cowboy hats and journey back to the old Wild West. A customer comes in seeking an iconic ’80s comic.

S5 E10
★ 8.0

Tell 'Em, Jim Lee!

Artist Jim Lee shares tales from the world of comics on the podcast; a comic book brings wedding bells to the Stash.

S5 E11
★ 0.0

Insta-Ming

When Ming gets a selfie stick, he tries to go viral by filming the Stash; Walt examines bootleg toys of an '80s blockbuster.

S5 E12
★ 0.0

Baby Jay

Jason Mewes brings his baby daughter to the Stash so she can meet the guys. Later, a customer sells a collection of comic-book Slurpee cups.

S5 E13
★ 0.0

Hometown Heroes

In the fifth-season finale, Phoenix Jones, a real-life superhero, visits the Stash and patrols Red Bank, N.J., with the guys. Later, Walt reminisces about an iconic Batman playset.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode
6 ★ 8.0 1
★ 8.0 Bucket List
★ 8.0 Bucket List
2 ★ 7.7 16
★ 8.4 Stan the Man
★ 7.3 The Clash at the Stash
4 ★ 7.7 1
★ 7.7 Heir Apparent
★ 7.7 Heir Apparent
5 ★ 7.6 10
★ 8.3 Stan Saves!
★ 6.6 Making Clay
3 ★ 7.3 4
★ 8.0 To the Bat Cave
★ 6.9 Dukes of Jersey