Eyewitness poster
★ 7.5
Eyewitness poster

Overall Rating

★ 7.5
S1 E8
#1
★ 8.4

The Larsons' Dog

Ryan romances Kamilah to get close to Lukas. As she tracks the killer, Helen develops an unexpected emotional connection with Ryan. Meanwhile, Gabe uncovers a clue to his wife's mysterious past.

S1 E9
#2
★ 8.4

Savior Unknown

Ryan struggles to cover his tracks. Meanwhile, Helen's dark past comes back and threatens her marriage as well as her ability to protect her family.

S1 E4
#3
★ 8.2

Crème Brûlée

Ryan tries to shut down Helen's case. Helen and Gabe's marriage is tested when Philip reveals a deep secret. Lukas creates a scandal to bury gay rumors at school.

S1 E5
#4
★ 8.1

The Lilies

Ryan interferes with an autopsy to stop Helen from getting closer to the truth. Philip deals with a surprise visit from his mom. Lukas struggles with anxiety about the murders.

S1 E7
#5
★ 8.1

They Lied

Lukas and Philip finally embrace their romance. Helen seeks Kamilah's help in protecting Lukas after she discovers evidence that the cabin shooter is alive and dangerous.

S1 E10
#6
★ 8.1

Mother's Day

Helen learns the identity of the killer; and races to find Philip and Lukas, who are missing.

S1 E3
#7
★ 8.0

Bella, Bella, Bella

Helen seeks help from Agent Kamilah Davis in tracking a potential witness. The boys skip school and head to a club in New York City that's not what Lukas expected.

S1 E2
#8
★ 7.9

Bless the Beast and the Children

Philip and Lukas find proof that the killer's alive. Helen tries not to let the case affect her marriage. A new head of the FBI task force is introduced.

S1 E6
#9
★ 7.9

The Yellow Couch

Helen is pulled away from her search for the murder weapon by Kamilah, who needs her help in finding a missing Sita. Lukas nears his dream sponsorship, but securing it may require an act of betrayal.

S1 E1
#10
★ 7.6

Buffalo '07

Teenagers Philip and Lukas meet to share a kiss—and witness a murder, which they don't report out of fear being outed. Complicating matters is the fact that Philip's foster mom is the sheriff, who's soon investigating the case.

S1 E1
#1
★ 7.6

Buffalo '07

Teenagers Philip and Lukas meet to share a kiss—and witness a murder, which they don't report out of fear being outed. Complicating matters is the fact that Philip's foster mom is the sheriff, who's soon investigating the case.

S1 E2
#2
★ 7.9

Bless the Beast and the Children

Philip and Lukas find proof that the killer's alive. Helen tries not to let the case affect her marriage. A new head of the FBI task force is introduced.

S1 E6
#3
★ 7.9

The Yellow Couch

Helen is pulled away from her search for the murder weapon by Kamilah, who needs her help in finding a missing Sita. Lukas nears his dream sponsorship, but securing it may require an act of betrayal.

S1 E3
#4
★ 8.0

Bella, Bella, Bella

Helen seeks help from Agent Kamilah Davis in tracking a potential witness. The boys skip school and head to a club in New York City that's not what Lukas expected.

S1 E5
#5
★ 8.1

The Lilies

Ryan interferes with an autopsy to stop Helen from getting closer to the truth. Philip deals with a surprise visit from his mom. Lukas struggles with anxiety about the murders.

S1 E7
#6
★ 8.1

They Lied

Lukas and Philip finally embrace their romance. Helen seeks Kamilah's help in protecting Lukas after she discovers evidence that the cabin shooter is alive and dangerous.

S1 E10
#7
★ 8.1

Mother's Day

Helen learns the identity of the killer; and races to find Philip and Lukas, who are missing.

S1 E4
#8
★ 8.2

Crème Brûlée

Ryan tries to shut down Helen's case. Helen and Gabe's marriage is tested when Philip reveals a deep secret. Lukas creates a scandal to bury gay rumors at school.

S1 E8
#9
★ 8.4

The Larsons' Dog

Ryan romances Kamilah to get close to Lukas. As she tracks the killer, Helen develops an unexpected emotional connection with Ryan. Meanwhile, Gabe uncovers a clue to his wife's mysterious past.

S1 E9
#10
★ 8.4

Savior Unknown

Ryan struggles to cover his tracks. Meanwhile, Helen's dark past comes back and threatens her marriage as well as her ability to protect her family.

S1 E1
★ 7.6

Buffalo '07

Teenagers Philip and Lukas meet to share a kiss—and witness a murder, which they don't report out of fear being outed. Complicating matters is the fact that Philip's foster mom is the sheriff, who's soon investigating the case.

S1 E2
★ 7.9

Bless the Beast and the Children

Philip and Lukas find proof that the killer's alive. Helen tries not to let the case affect her marriage. A new head of the FBI task force is introduced.

S1 E3
★ 8.0

Bella, Bella, Bella

Helen seeks help from Agent Kamilah Davis in tracking a potential witness. The boys skip school and head to a club in New York City that's not what Lukas expected.

S1 E4
★ 8.2

Crème Brûlée

Ryan tries to shut down Helen's case. Helen and Gabe's marriage is tested when Philip reveals a deep secret. Lukas creates a scandal to bury gay rumors at school.

S1 E5
★ 8.1

The Lilies

Ryan interferes with an autopsy to stop Helen from getting closer to the truth. Philip deals with a surprise visit from his mom. Lukas struggles with anxiety about the murders.

S1 E6
★ 7.9

The Yellow Couch

Helen is pulled away from her search for the murder weapon by Kamilah, who needs her help in finding a missing Sita. Lukas nears his dream sponsorship, but securing it may require an act of betrayal.

S1 E7
★ 8.1

They Lied

Lukas and Philip finally embrace their romance. Helen seeks Kamilah's help in protecting Lukas after she discovers evidence that the cabin shooter is alive and dangerous.

S1 E8
★ 8.4

The Larsons' Dog

Ryan romances Kamilah to get close to Lukas. As she tracks the killer, Helen develops an unexpected emotional connection with Ryan. Meanwhile, Gabe uncovers a clue to his wife's mysterious past.

S1 E9
★ 8.4

Savior Unknown

Ryan struggles to cover his tracks. Meanwhile, Helen's dark past comes back and threatens her marriage as well as her ability to protect her family.

S1 E10
★ 8.1

Mother's Day

Helen learns the identity of the killer; and races to find Philip and Lukas, who are missing.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode Rating Range
1 ★ 8.1 10
★ 8.4 The Larsons' Dog
★ 7.6 Buffalo '07