Review poster
★ 8.4
Review poster

Overall Rating

★ 8.4
S2 E8
#1
★ 9.0

Murder, Magic 8-Ball, Procrastination

Forrest allows a Magic 8-Ball to dictate his decisions for a day, runs into a paradox when faced with the task of procrastinating and faces his toughest review yet.

S2 E4
#2
★ 8.9

Cult, Perfect Body

Forrest starts a cult and tries to sculpt a perfect body by undergoing a series of enhancements.

S2 E6
#3
★ 8.7

William Tell, Grant A Wish, Rowboat

Forrest sits in a rowboat; convinces his father to re-create William Tell's archery feat; and reluctantly grants his son's birthday wish.

S2 E1
#4
★ 8.5

Bare-Knuckle Brawl, Blackmail, Glory Hole

Forrest gets into a fight with a stranger, blackmails his new girlfriend and discovers the pleasures of a glory hole.

S2 E3
#5
★ 8.4

Falsely Accused, Sleep With Your Teacher, Little Person

Forrest gets framed for a crime, has sex with a high-school teacher, and experiences the life of a little person.

S2 E7
#6
★ 8.3

Buried Alive, Giving Six Stars, Public Speaking

Forrest spends a day in a coffin; wonders what to do with a request for a six-star rating; and makes a public-speaking appearance.

S2 E2
#7
★ 7.7

Curing a Gay, Joining the Mile-High Club

Forrest attempts to turn a young gay man straight and finds that having sex on an airplane is surprisingly difficult.

S2 E5
#8
★ 7.6

Catfishing, Haunted House

Forrest reconnects with an ex on his first foray into catfishing and discovers different kinds of ghosts while sleeping in a haunted house.

S1 E1
#9
★ 0.0

Stealing, Addiction, Prom

Forrest is requested to review shoplifting, cocaine addiction, and going to the prom (although he is in his forties).

S1 E2
#10
★ 0.0

Sex Tape, Racist, Hunting

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including making a sex tape, being a racist, and hunting.

S2 E5
#1
★ 7.6

Catfishing, Haunted House

Forrest reconnects with an ex on his first foray into catfishing and discovers different kinds of ghosts while sleeping in a haunted house.

S2 E2
#2
★ 7.7

Curing a Gay, Joining the Mile-High Club

Forrest attempts to turn a young gay man straight and finds that having sex on an airplane is surprisingly difficult.

S2 E7
#3
★ 8.3

Buried Alive, Giving Six Stars, Public Speaking

Forrest spends a day in a coffin; wonders what to do with a request for a six-star rating; and makes a public-speaking appearance.

S2 E3
#4
★ 8.4

Falsely Accused, Sleep With Your Teacher, Little Person

Forrest gets framed for a crime, has sex with a high-school teacher, and experiences the life of a little person.

S2 E1
#5
★ 8.5

Bare-Knuckle Brawl, Blackmail, Glory Hole

Forrest gets into a fight with a stranger, blackmails his new girlfriend and discovers the pleasures of a glory hole.

S2 E6
#6
★ 8.7

William Tell, Grant A Wish, Rowboat

Forrest sits in a rowboat; convinces his father to re-create William Tell's archery feat; and reluctantly grants his son's birthday wish.

S2 E4
#7
★ 8.9

Cult, Perfect Body

Forrest starts a cult and tries to sculpt a perfect body by undergoing a series of enhancements.

S2 E8
#8
★ 9.0

Murder, Magic 8-Ball, Procrastination

Forrest allows a Magic 8-Ball to dictate his decisions for a day, runs into a paradox when faced with the task of procrastinating and faces his toughest review yet.

S1 E1
★ 0.0

Stealing, Addiction, Prom

Forrest is requested to review shoplifting, cocaine addiction, and going to the prom (although he is in his forties).

S1 E2
★ 0.0

Sex Tape, Racist, Hunting

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including making a sex tape, being a racist, and hunting.

S1 E3
★ 0.0

Pancakes, Divorce, Pancakes

Forrest hits rock bottom after divorcing Suzanne and forcing himself to eat an unhealthy number of pancakes.

S1 E4
★ 0.0

Celebrity, Batman

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including sleeping with a celebrity and being Batman.

S1 E5
★ 0.0

Best Friend, Space

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including having a best friend and going to space.

S1 E6
★ 0.0

Road Rage, Orgy

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences that include road rage and going to an orgy.

S1 E7
★ 0.0

Revenge, Getting Rich, Aching

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences that include revenge, getting rich quick, and being institutionalized.

S1 E8
★ 0.0

Marry, Run, Party

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including getting married, running from the law, and being the life of the party.

S1 E9
★ 0.0

Quitting, Last Day, Irish

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including quitting your job, Carpe Diem, and being Irish.

S2 E1
★ 8.5

Bare-Knuckle Brawl, Blackmail, Glory Hole

Forrest gets into a fight with a stranger, blackmails his new girlfriend and discovers the pleasures of a glory hole.

S2 E2
★ 7.7

Curing a Gay, Joining the Mile-High Club

Forrest attempts to turn a young gay man straight and finds that having sex on an airplane is surprisingly difficult.

S2 E3
★ 8.4

Falsely Accused, Sleep With Your Teacher, Little Person

Forrest gets framed for a crime, has sex with a high-school teacher, and experiences the life of a little person.

S2 E4
★ 8.9

Cult, Perfect Body

Forrest starts a cult and tries to sculpt a perfect body by undergoing a series of enhancements.

S2 E5
★ 7.6

Catfishing, Haunted House

Forrest reconnects with an ex on his first foray into catfishing and discovers different kinds of ghosts while sleeping in a haunted house.

S2 E6
★ 8.7

William Tell, Grant A Wish, Rowboat

Forrest sits in a rowboat; convinces his father to re-create William Tell's archery feat; and reluctantly grants his son's birthday wish.

S2 E7
★ 8.3

Buried Alive, Giving Six Stars, Public Speaking

Forrest spends a day in a coffin; wonders what to do with a request for a six-star rating; and makes a public-speaking appearance.

S2 E8
★ 9.0

Murder, Magic 8-Ball, Procrastination

Forrest allows a Magic 8-Ball to dictate his decisions for a day, runs into a paradox when faced with the task of procrastinating and faces his toughest review yet.

S2 E9
★ 0.0

Being Happy, Pillow Fight, Imaginary Friend

Forrest reviews always being happy ("Happiness"), "Pillow Fights" and having an "Imaginary Friend"

S2 E10
★ 0.0

Conspiracy Theory

Forrest makes a disconcerting discovery while researching conspiracy theories and finds himself on the run from a man-hunter.

S3 E1
★ 0.0

Locorito, Pet Euthanasia, Dream

After surviving last season's big fall, Forrest gets back to work by reviewing a Mexican restaurant's new product, the experience of putting a pet to sleep and what it's like to live his dream.

S3 E2
★ 0.0

Co-Host, Ass-Slap, Helen Keller, Forgiveness

Forrest swaps roles with A.J., tries to live like Helen Keller and visits Suzanne to review forgiveness.

S3 E3
★ 0.0

Cryogenics, Lightning, Last Review

Forrest sets out to cryogenically freeze himself and get struck by lightning, then receives a surprising message from Suzanne.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode Rating Range
2 ★ 8.4 8
★ 9.0 Murder, Magic 8-Ball, Procrastination
★ 7.6 Catfishing, Haunted House