Is It Cake? poster
★ 6.0
Is It Cake? poster

Overall Rating

★ 6.0
S1 E8
#1
★ 7.0

Winner Fakes All!

The top three contenders design the cakes of their dreams for a shot at a $50,000 prize. Guest judges: Loni Love, Bobby Moynihan and Karamo Brown.

S1 E4
#2
★ 6.8

Imposter in Aisle 5

Veggies, challah and cellophane-wrapped steak? Groceries never tasted so sweet. Guest judges: Courtney Parchman, Finesse Mitchell and Farley Elliott.

S2 E1
#3
★ 6.8

Everything Is Cake!

The bakers dig deep to craft incredible, edible objects with personal significance. Guest judges: Chrishell Stause, Blake Anderson and Maz Jobrani.

S2 E8
#4
★ 6.8

Winner Cakes All!

With $75,000 on the line, the three remaining bakers face a final full of surprises. Guest judges: Jade Catta-Preta, Chris Redd and Taylor Tomlinson.

S1 E7
#5
★ 6.7

Toying Around

It's time for the bakers to create cakes that look like toys. Let the games begin! Guest judges: Brittany Broski, Heidi Gardner and Dan Ahdoot.

S1 E6
#6
★ 6.6

Garage Mirage

Cake takes the form of garage sale scores, including a bowling pin and an antique radio. Guest judges: Tony Rock, King Princess and Lyric Lewis.

S2 E2
#7
★ 6.6

Body by Cake

A gym-themed challenge finds the cake artists scrambling to imitate exercise equipment. Guest judges: Nico Santos, Joel McHale and Ally Love.

S2 E6
#8
★ 6.6

So Fresh and So Cake

From frosted toilets to fondant toothpaste: Will a bathroom theme send the bakers' dreams down the drain? Guest judges: Charli, Heidi and Dixie D’Amelio.

S1 E3
#9
★ 6.5

Fake by the Ocean

Clever contestants camouflage their cakes to look like things you'd see at the beach. Guest judges: Camille Kostek, Chris Witaske and Kellee Edwards.

S1 E5
#10
★ 6.5

Cake Crashers

Remarkable cake art mimics items you'd find at a party like red Solo cups and salty snacks. Guest judges: Arthuro Castro, Rebecca Black and Jon Gabrus.

S2 E3
#1
★ 5.1

Cake University

School's in session with A+ cakes that look like they came from a college dorm. Guest judges: Chris Witaske, Kirby Howell-Baptiste and Chloe Fineman.

S1 E1
#2
★ 6.0

Fast-Food Fakeout

Flavorful cakes pose as fast-food favorites like burgers, tacos and breakfast sandwiches. Guest judges: Daym Drops, Fortune Feimster and Ronnie Woo.

S2 E7
#3
★ 6.0

Cake Me Out to the Ballgame

A stressful semifinal brings sports-themed cakes — and a high-stakes double elimination. Game on! Guest judges: Jeff Dye, Chiney Ogwumike and Flula Borg.

S1 E2
#4
★ 6.3

Phony Fashion

Bakers create delicious decoys of shoes, designer bags and other department store finds. Guest judges: Hester Sunshine, Jason Bolden and Michael Yo.

S2 E4
#5
★ 6.4

That 90's Cake

A retro challenge takes contestants back to the '90s with VCRs, Dr. Martens and more. Guest judges: Anna Camp, Melissa Villaseñor and Joel Kim Booster.

S1 E3
#6
★ 6.5

Fake by the Ocean

Clever contestants camouflage their cakes to look like things you'd see at the beach. Guest judges: Camille Kostek, Chris Witaske and Kellee Edwards.

S1 E5
#7
★ 6.5

Cake Crashers

Remarkable cake art mimics items you'd find at a party like red Solo cups and salty snacks. Guest judges: Arthuro Castro, Rebecca Black and Jon Gabrus.

S2 E5
#8
★ 6.5

S'more Cake Please

Bakers re-create the great outdoors with realistic cakes inspired by camping gear. Guest judges: Brandon Kyle Goodman, Cristela Alonzo and Kate Flannery.

S1 E6
#9
★ 6.6

Garage Mirage

Cake takes the form of garage sale scores, including a bowling pin and an antique radio. Guest judges: Tony Rock, King Princess and Lyric Lewis.

S2 E2
#10
★ 6.6

Body by Cake

A gym-themed challenge finds the cake artists scrambling to imitate exercise equipment. Guest judges: Nico Santos, Joel McHale and Ally Love.

S1 E1
★ 6.0

Fast-Food Fakeout

Flavorful cakes pose as fast-food favorites like burgers, tacos and breakfast sandwiches. Guest judges: Daym Drops, Fortune Feimster and Ronnie Woo.

S1 E2
★ 6.3

Phony Fashion

Bakers create delicious decoys of shoes, designer bags and other department store finds. Guest judges: Hester Sunshine, Jason Bolden and Michael Yo.

S1 E3
★ 6.5

Fake by the Ocean

Clever contestants camouflage their cakes to look like things you'd see at the beach. Guest judges: Camille Kostek, Chris Witaske and Kellee Edwards.

S1 E4
★ 6.8

Imposter in Aisle 5

Veggies, challah and cellophane-wrapped steak? Groceries never tasted so sweet. Guest judges: Courtney Parchman, Finesse Mitchell and Farley Elliott.

S1 E5
★ 6.5

Cake Crashers

Remarkable cake art mimics items you'd find at a party like red Solo cups and salty snacks. Guest judges: Arthuro Castro, Rebecca Black and Jon Gabrus.

S1 E6
★ 6.6

Garage Mirage

Cake takes the form of garage sale scores, including a bowling pin and an antique radio. Guest judges: Tony Rock, King Princess and Lyric Lewis.

S1 E7
★ 6.7

Toying Around

It's time for the bakers to create cakes that look like toys. Let the games begin! Guest judges: Brittany Broski, Heidi Gardner and Dan Ahdoot.

S1 E8
★ 7.0

Winner Fakes All!

The top three contenders design the cakes of their dreams for a shot at a $50,000 prize. Guest judges: Loni Love, Bobby Moynihan and Karamo Brown.

S2 E1
★ 6.8

Everything Is Cake!

The bakers dig deep to craft incredible, edible objects with personal significance. Guest judges: Chrishell Stause, Blake Anderson and Maz Jobrani.

S2 E2
★ 6.6

Body by Cake

A gym-themed challenge finds the cake artists scrambling to imitate exercise equipment. Guest judges: Nico Santos, Joel McHale and Ally Love.

S2 E3
★ 5.1

Cake University

School's in session with A+ cakes that look like they came from a college dorm. Guest judges: Chris Witaske, Kirby Howell-Baptiste and Chloe Fineman.

S2 E4
★ 6.4

That 90's Cake

A retro challenge takes contestants back to the '90s with VCRs, Dr. Martens and more. Guest judges: Anna Camp, Melissa Villaseñor and Joel Kim Booster.

S2 E5
★ 6.5

S'more Cake Please

Bakers re-create the great outdoors with realistic cakes inspired by camping gear. Guest judges: Brandon Kyle Goodman, Cristela Alonzo and Kate Flannery.

S2 E6
★ 6.6

So Fresh and So Cake

From frosted toilets to fondant toothpaste: Will a bathroom theme send the bakers' dreams down the drain? Guest judges: Charli, Heidi and Dixie D’Amelio.

S2 E7
★ 6.0

Cake Me Out to the Ballgame

A stressful semifinal brings sports-themed cakes — and a high-stakes double elimination. Game on! Guest judges: Jeff Dye, Chiney Ogwumike and Flula Borg.

S2 E8
★ 6.8

Winner Cakes All!

With $75,000 on the line, the three remaining bakers face a final full of surprises. Guest judges: Jade Catta-Preta, Chris Redd and Taylor Tomlinson.

S3 E1
★ 0.0

Cake Whodunit

The first batch of bakers create incredible objects out of cake with a personal touch. Guest judges: Jay Pharoah, Lauren Lapkus and London Hughes.

S3 E2
★ 0.0

Swimming with Cakes

The next wave of bakers make a splash with pool party-themed counterfeit confections. Guest judges: Oscar Nuñez, Jillian Bell and Kamie Crawford.

S3 E3
★ 0.0

Head-to-Head Battle Royale

In a spooky showdown, bakers bring Dracula, Frankenstein and more to life. Guest judges: Dulcé Sloan, Chris Witaske and Liza Koshy.

S3 E4
★ 0.0

Knock Knock...Cake Service!

In the first-ever team challenge, bakers attempt to deliver realistic room service dishes. Guest judges: Michael Ealy, Heather McMahan and Beck Bennett.

S3 E5
★ 0.0

Welcome to the Jungle

Bakers answer the call of the wild by camouflaging cakes as a snake, an iguana and... a log. Guest judges: Sam Morril, Danielle Pinnock and Christina P.

S3 E6
★ 0.0

Cake on Fire

The heat is on for a fiery new challenge. Will judges spot the correct firehouse fakes? Guest judges: Sherry Cola, Adam Shapiro and Storm Reid.

S3 E7
★ 0.0

Cakes Ahoy!

For the semifinals, two bakers walk the plank after a pirate-themed double elimination. Guest judges: Emma Hernan, Justin Willman and Lana Condor.

S3 E8
★ 0.0

Winner Cakes All!

With $50,000 up for grabs, the remaining bakers create cakes that represent their families. Guest judges: Taran Killam, Ego Nwodim and Chris Kattan.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode Rating Range
1 ★ 6.6 8
★ 7.0 Winner Fakes All!
★ 6.0 Fast-Food Fakeout
2 ★ 6.3 8
★ 6.8 Everything Is Cake!
★ 5.1 Cake University