One of Us Is Lying poster
★ 6.9
One of Us Is Lying poster

Overall Rating

★ 6.9
S2 E7
#1
★ 8.3

Simon Says Time Out

The Murder Club and Vanessa form an unexpected alliance to uncover the truth about Simon Says.

S2 E8
#2
★ 8.3

Simon Says Game Over

The Murder Club hatches a risky plan to stop Simon Says, but what they don't know could hurt them.

S2 E6
#3
★ 8.0

Simon Says You Better Pray

Vanessa doubles down on her investigation into the Murder Club and finds key evidence.

S2 E4
#4
★ 7.9

Simon Says Gotcha!

The Murder Club works to find the truth about Giselle. Vanessa digs deeper into Halloween night.

S2 E5
#5
★ 7.8

Simon Says Ho Ho Ho!

As Bayview celebrates the holidays, the Murder Club makes a difficult and shocking decision.

S1 E6
#6
★ 7.7

One of Us Is Dancing!

The "Bayview Four" investigate their main suspect at the Homecoming dance.

S2 E3
#7
★ 7.7

Simon Says Let's Get Personal

Demands from Simon Says get stranger and more personal. Someone from Jake's past reappears.

S1 E8
#8
★ 7.5

One of Us Is Dead

The truth about Simon's murder is revealed on Halloween night.

S2 E2
#9
★ 7.5

Simon Says Tick Tock

Simon Says blackmails the Murder Club with a surprising demand. Vanessa holds a rally for Jake.

S1 E4
#10
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Famous

The case makes national news; Nate confronts his past; Bronwyn makes a surprising discovery.

S1 E1
#1
★ 6.9

Pilot

Five students enter detention, but only four come out alive and they all have secrets to kill for.

S1 E3
#2
★ 7.1

One of Us Is Not Like the Others

The "Bayview Four's" secrets start to drop; Cooper faces the biggest test of his sports career.

S1 E2
#3
★ 7.2

One of Us Is Grieving

The "Bayview Four" go to Simon's wake and become official suspects in his murder.

S2 E1
#4
★ 7.2

Simon Says Game On

The aftermath of Jake's death begins to unfold at Bayview. The Murder Club faces a new threat.

S1 E4
#5
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Famous

The case makes national news; Nate confronts his past; Bronwyn makes a surprising discovery.

S1 E5
#6
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Cracking

The police pressure the suspects; a leaked piece of evidence puts a student in the spotlight.

S1 E7
#7
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Not Giving Up

The "Bayview Four" race against the clock to exonerate one of their own before it's too late.

S1 E8
#8
★ 7.5

One of Us Is Dead

The truth about Simon's murder is revealed on Halloween night.

S2 E2
#9
★ 7.5

Simon Says Tick Tock

Simon Says blackmails the Murder Club with a surprising demand. Vanessa holds a rally for Jake.

S1 E6
#10
★ 7.7

One of Us Is Dancing!

The "Bayview Four" investigate their main suspect at the Homecoming dance.

S1 E1
★ 6.9

Pilot

Five students enter detention, but only four come out alive and they all have secrets to kill for.

S1 E2
★ 7.2

One of Us Is Grieving

The "Bayview Four" go to Simon's wake and become official suspects in his murder.

S1 E3
★ 7.1

One of Us Is Not Like the Others

The "Bayview Four's" secrets start to drop; Cooper faces the biggest test of his sports career.

S1 E4
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Famous

The case makes national news; Nate confronts his past; Bronwyn makes a surprising discovery.

S1 E5
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Cracking

The police pressure the suspects; a leaked piece of evidence puts a student in the spotlight.

S1 E6
★ 7.7

One of Us Is Dancing!

The "Bayview Four" investigate their main suspect at the Homecoming dance.

S1 E7
★ 7.4

One of Us Is Not Giving Up

The "Bayview Four" race against the clock to exonerate one of their own before it's too late.

S1 E8
★ 7.5

One of Us Is Dead

The truth about Simon's murder is revealed on Halloween night.

S2 E1
★ 7.2

Simon Says Game On

The aftermath of Jake's death begins to unfold at Bayview. The Murder Club faces a new threat.

S2 E2
★ 7.5

Simon Says Tick Tock

Simon Says blackmails the Murder Club with a surprising demand. Vanessa holds a rally for Jake.

S2 E3
★ 7.7

Simon Says Let's Get Personal

Demands from Simon Says get stranger and more personal. Someone from Jake's past reappears.

S2 E4
★ 7.9

Simon Says Gotcha!

The Murder Club works to find the truth about Giselle. Vanessa digs deeper into Halloween night.

S2 E5
★ 7.8

Simon Says Ho Ho Ho!

As Bayview celebrates the holidays, the Murder Club makes a difficult and shocking decision.

S2 E6
★ 8.0

Simon Says You Better Pray

Vanessa doubles down on her investigation into the Murder Club and finds key evidence.

S2 E7
★ 8.3

Simon Says Time Out

The Murder Club and Vanessa form an unexpected alliance to uncover the truth about Simon Says.

S2 E8
★ 8.3

Simon Says Game Over

The Murder Club hatches a risky plan to stop Simon Says, but what they don't know could hurt them.

Season Average Rating Episodes Best Episode Worst Episode Rating Range
2 ★ 7.8 8
★ 8.3 Simon Says Time Out
★ 7.2 Simon Says Game On
1 ★ 7.3 8
★ 7.7 One of Us Is Dancing!
★ 6.9 Pilot